NextElection - Make it count!
India
English
0
  • Search

  • Updates
  • Topics
  • Featured
  • Leaders
  • Parties

AboutContactTermsPrivacy
    ⚡ Powered by MainCross
    Dim the Navigation panel when not in use
    Nationalism scored over concerns of tribal people
    Bharatiya Janata PartyArticle02 Jun, 2019
    Last edited: 30 Jul, 2019, 5:38 PM

    Nationalism scored over concerns of tribal people

    Issues related to tribal communities and forest dwellers had gained public and media attention just ahead of the 2019 general elections, failed to translate into electoral gains for opposition parties

    • Issues related to tribal communities and forest dwellers had gained public and media attention just ahead of India’s recently-concluded 2019 parliamentary elections.
    • However, the outrage on the issues failed to translate into electoral gains for opposition parties. Of the 47 seats in the elections, reserved for scheduled tribes, the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party won more than half and even improved its performance from the 2014 elections.
    • The tribal community didn’t vote as a single block and were swayed by BJP’s focus on nationalism, emphasise civil society groups and political experts.

    Controversies and uproar around tribal issues over the past few years failed to make a dent in the recent elections with the tribal community in fact voting to reinstate the government held responsible for many of these issues. The first tenure of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government saw tribal people facing displacement from forests, debate around poor implementation of the Forest Rights Act 2006 and dilutions in the green laws hampering tribal rights. But the issues did not show an impact in the recently concluded 2019 parliamentary elections in India where the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won more seats reserved for scheduled tribes in the 2019 elections, as compared to the 2014 elections.

    Of the 543 seats in Lok Sabha, 47 parliamentary seats are reserved for candidates of the scheduled tribes and the BJP won well over half of them in these elections, despite the agitations on tribal issues preceding the elections.

    In September 2018, thousands of farmers and tribal people marched to the national capital to protest against several issues including poor implementation of the Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006.

    Subsequently, just ahead of the 2019 elections, in February 2019, the Supreme Court of India directed the state governments to evict those tribal people whose claims under the FRA 2006 had been rejected. However, the NDA government was soon cornered by opposition parties on the issue following which the government approached the SC and the eviction order was stayed. The order could have impacted nearly two million tribal families which means 8-10 million people. The opposition parties, especially the Indian National Congress led by Rahul Gandhi, had also aggressively taken up the issue. But it didn’t bear any major electoral fruit for them.

    In March 2019, the central government’s move to amend the Indian Forest Act (IFA) 1927 gained attention. The proposed amendments plan to give more powers to the forest authorities and encourage large scale afforestation but experts stressed that it could also lead to an increase in injustice to forest dwellers.

    Of the 47 seats reserved for candidates from scheduled tribes, in 2019 elections, BJP won 31 seats (65.95 percent), while the Indian National Congress won only four seats. The remaining seats were won by independent leaders and regional parties such as Telangana Rashtra Samithi, Yuvajana Sramika Rythu Congress Party, Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Nationalist Congress Party, Shiv Sena, Naga Peoples Front, Biju Janata Dal, National Peoples Party, and Mizo National Front. In the 2014 elections, BJP had won 27 (57.44) of the 47 seats while Congress had won five of them.

    In 2019 elections, BJP improved its performance in parliamentary seats reserved for scheduled tribes as compared to 2014 elections. Source: Election Commission of India.

    Mongabay-India’s analysis of the results also shows that even in the states having a sizeable population of tribal people, BJP scored better. For instance, BJP won three of the four seats reserved for tribals in Chhattisgarh, three of the five reserved seats in Jharkhand, all six reserved seats in Madhya Pradesh, all four reserved seats in Gujarat, three of the four reserved seats in Maharashtra while one was won by its ally Shiv Sena, all three reserved seats in Rajasthan and both the reserved seats in West Bengal.

    Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay, a political analyst, explained that “We cannot look at the tribal community across India as a homogenous voting community because the tribal people in the Hindi heartland have to be delinked from those in the northeast and from those in the southern state.”

    Mukhopadhyay emphasised that over the last four decades, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) through a concerted outreach programme in the tribal seats in the north and western India, has been able to make them (tribal people) a part of the Hindutva (Hindu nationalism) constituency. RSS is the ideological parent of the BJP.

    “This has played a very major role in the reserved seats in the Hindi heartland. That is why you see stalwart tribal leaders from regional parties like Shibu Soren (of the JMM) losing to the BJP. This means that regional parties which used to voice tribal concerns are no longer being looked as alternatives. For instance, see the way BJP has performed in the last several elections in Chhattisgarh. Basically, the RSS has reached out to tribal people and conducted a campaign that you are part of the larger Hindu society,” Mukhopadhyay told Mongabay-India.

    Parties focused on tribal people failed too

    It is not just the regional parties that failed to rally tribal people behind them. Even a party like Bharatiya Tribal Party, founded by a tribal leader, focusing mainly on the welfare of tribal communities failed to win even a single seat.

    “Why will tribal people vote for someone who is planning to push them out of the forest which is their home? This election result is due to the manipulation of the electronic voting machines. If elections are conducted by ballot paper today the picture will change. The issues of forest dwellers and tribal people are the main issue for us and we will continue to fight for them,” Chhotubhai Amarsinh Vasava, who is the founder of the Bharatiya Tribal Party, told Mongabay-India.

    BTP fought on 17 seats across constituencies in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, and Rajasthan but failed to win any seat.

    Nationalism scored over concerns of tribal people

    Experts believe it was the BJP’s message of nationalism – of putting nation above everything else – which found resonance over everything else.

    “The problem is that this election was fought on non-issues. Issues like displacement, mining, and implementation of forest rights did not find resonance in the 2019 Lok Sabha elections. In the past few years, issues of farmers, the stress in the rural sector and problems faced by tribal people got the attention but BJP was successful in changing the narrative through the issue of nationalism. So, even if a farmer is facing problems he is voting for the BJP in the name of strengthening the country. It was not an issue-based election,” Alok Shukla of the Chhattisgarh Bachao Andolan told Mongabay-India.

    Explaining further the reasons behind BJP’s success, Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay stressed that the underlying message of the entire campaign was to put nation above all other issues.

    “They were made to feel that it is the time to think for the nation and not just for the small personal demands. That is what I think has prevailed in this election,” said Mukhopadhyay.

    But leaders stressed that it is not an end to their struggles for ensuring the welfare of the tribal community.

    A senior Congress leader, who wished to remain anonymous, said throughout the 2019 elections they highlighted the issues of tribal people not getting justice, but it didn’t translate in support for them.

    “Our party was very vocal about the problem of the tribal community. We were the ones who enacted the FRA 2006. Our party’s president Rahul Gandhi had even asked the chief ministers of Congress-led governments in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Chhattisgarh to oppose SC’s decision and file a review petition. We will continue working on the issue,” said the Congress leader.

    BTP’s founder Vasava too said that they would continue their struggle and unite tribal leaders from across India under one single platform.

    “We are not giving up as no one is going to fight for the tribal people. We will take this struggle to a logical conclusion ourselves because no matter who forms the government they are not going to work for the welfare of the tribal community. Over the next few years, we will unite all tribal leaders under one platform,” Vasava stressed.

    Article by Mayank Aggarwal, first published on Mongabay.com.

    Mongabay

    Mongabay

    @Mongabay

    Want to be informed when this author publishes the next article?

    Save, embed, share, report
    0comments
    About this channel
    Bharatiya Janata Party

    Bharatiya Janata Party

    Political Party

    India

    3/10PeopleScore
    301 / 545 Seats

    More from this channel

    Select between trending, latest and important content.
    Article22 Feb, 2021

    BJP’s strategy to expand south: Magnifying its presence before elections to appear more powerful

    The UPA government in Puducherry has lost a majority due to MLAs resigning. The term was anyway going to end in 3 months. And yet BJP wanted to form the government in spite of being a minor party
    Article09 Dec, 2020

    BJP's Rath Yatra was held in late 80s and early 90s. The Babri Masjid was demolished in 1992. What happened in Tamil Nadu 28 years later?

    BJP's Rath Yatra was very significant for the party in gaining popularity. However, it was not significant in the south. Here is what happened when the party held a 'Vel Yatra' in Tamil Nadu.
    Opinion08 Jun, 2020

    BJP's performance and Modi's popularity have altered the dynamic of regional party politics in India

    In this excerpt, Aiyar Yamini & I explore how the BJP's centralization has affected the bargaining power & electoral prospects of regional parties. In this piece, we argue that the electoral performance of the BJP, and the popularity of Narendra...

    ThePrint

    BJP’s undiluted power at the Centre has weakened the bargaining position of regional parties

    Yamini Aiyar & Neelanjan Sircar write in Contemporary South Asia journal on how BJP's electoral performance and Modi's popularity have altered the...
    Link28 Apr, 2020
    The Week

    BJP issues show-cause notice to UP MLA for remarks against Muslims

    Party chief J.P. Nadda has pulled up the state brass for not taking quick action
    Opinion17 Apr, 2020

    Research

    Its A Research Phase of Finding Leadership or I Guess Potential Powers of A Human Being What Matters For Us All We Know. Rest Few Words From A Story Sir : They all thanked the mouse and flew away together, united in their strength. Moral: When you work together, you are stronger.
    Update27 Jan, 2020

    BJP income in 2018-19 was ₹2,410 crores, double of previous year

    BJP’s income in 2018-19 was ₹2,410 crores while its income during the previous year i.e. 2017-18 was ₹1,027 crores. In other words, income has more than doubled. This is most likely because of 2019 being an election year.
    Opinion06 Dec, 2019

    The opposition’s surrender to Hindutva has only raised the bar for what can polarise voters

    I write in The Print: Hindutva as electoral politics spreads primarily through polarisation. Here’s an early example. M.S. Golwalkar, the influential second chief of the RSS, told Amul’s Verghese Kurien that the cow protection issue was for him a...

    ThePrint

    As India becomes de facto Hindu Rashtra, BJP looks for new ways to polarise voters

    The opposition’s surrender to Hindutva has only raised the bar for what can polarise voters. Enter NRC and CAB.
    Article01 Nov, 2019

    Lok Sabha vs Assembly elections 2019: Setback for BJP?

    Analysis using Maharashtra and Haryana assembly election results
    Link31 Oct, 2019
    varunstext

    Lok Sabha vs Assembly elections 2019: Setback for BJP?

    Analysis using Maharashtra and Haryana assembly election results This is the...
    Article16 Oct, 2019

    BJP’s Unlimited Money

    Considering the allegations are true that BJP is poaching MLAs, RS.50 crore to 20 MLAs would mean RS.1000 crore ($14B USD).
    Link19 Sep, 2019
    Hindustan Times

    What the 2024 battle may look like

    The BJP is preparing for a third term. The Congress is still reeling from its...
    Link27 Aug, 2019
    https://www.livemint.com

    BJP staring at leadership vacuum after successive demise of party veterans

    BJP lost five senior leaders in last one year.Swaraj and Jaitley have groomed an...
    Link20 Aug, 2019
    News18

    Hamstrung by Ideological Opportunism, Opposition Parties Limp as BJP Races Ahead

    While the ruling party seems true to its core commitments of nationalism and...
    Link23 Jun, 2019
    The Indian Express

    Bias against Modi govt: BJP slams US report on religious freedom

    The remarks come ahead of US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s scheduled visit to...
    Article02 Jun, 2019

    Nationalism scored over concerns of tribal people

    Issues related to tribal communities and forest dwellers had gained public and media attention just ahead of the 2019 general elections, failed to translate into electoral gains for opposition parties
    Opinion01 Jun, 2019

    Army is just another tool for BJP to garner votes. Most anti national.

    The Hindu

    Kargil war veteran declared a foreigner

    Lt. (retd.) Mohammed Sanaullah's family approaches the Gauhati High Court on Wednesday, less than 24 hours after he was sent to a detention centre for...
    Opinion24 May, 2019

    Better than the others

    Apart from the fact that some members of BJP are extremists, by and large the party is doing good work for India. The leadership is sane and effective. It has taken the biggest challenges head on. It is also perceived as non-corrupt.
    Poll23 May, 2019

    Did you expect the BJP to win by the margin it has?

    Trends showed the BJP on course to better its 2014 tally and of winning about 300 seats.

    Yes

    28.6% votes

    No

    71.4% votes
    7 votes received Poll has expired
    Link21 May, 2019
    The Hindu

    Analysis: The pros and cons of the Trinamool and the BJP, as West Bengal waits

    While the BJP clearly lacks a face, yet it has a reasonably better middle...
    Opinion17 May, 2019

    Will higher voter turnout help or hurt BJP?

    What are the trends in turnout so far? What does it mean for the BJP? I dig into the data to provide some insights using election results and satellite imagery. A big thank you to Shamindra Roy for processing the satellite data! In the previous...

    India Today

    Will higher voter turnout help or hurt BJP?

    In the previous election, during the Modi wave, India saw its highest ever turnout at 66 per cent. Surprisingly, the turnout numbers so far in 2019...

    Select your country

    The NextElection network is fully customized to each country.

    Looks like you are in USA. Click on your country flag to proceed.

    India
    United States of America
    New Zealand