NextElection - Make it count!
India
English
0
  • Search

  • Updates
  • Topics
  • Featured
  • Leaders
  • Parties

AboutContactTermsPrivacy
    ⚡ Powered by MainCross
    Dim the Navigation panel when not in use
    maori rightsArticle01 Sep, 2020
    Last edited: 01 Sep, 2020, 7:14 PM

    Two inquiries find unfair treatment and healthcare for Māori. This is how we fix it

    An independent Māori authority with the power to monitor and report on service providers’ effectiveness, but also the power to discontinue their funding, would ensure meaningful Māori voice.

    Unfair and avoidable differences in health outcomes separate Māori from other citizens, said a report from this month’s parliamentary select committee inquiry into Māori health.

    The report focused mainly on why cancer screening and treatment are not as effective for Māori.

    But it also showed clinical and policy decisions don’t always give Māori the same chance at good health as other people, and identified significant systemic racism in the health system.

    Among the recommendations was the setting up of a new agency focused on improving Māori health, to be run by Māori. Similar recommendations have been made in the past, but have not been implemented.

    The causes of ill health

    Contemporary health policy research is heavily influenced by the argument that inequitable health outcomes are partly caused by social determinants of health. This includes things such as poor housing, low incomes and limited education increasing people’s chances of getting sick.

    Read more: Bandaid or cure: a major health review remains split on how to reduce persistent inequalities for Māori

    These ideas help policymakers think about the causes of ill health and develop coherent policy responses. But they only address part of the problem.

    For example, racism is a political determinant of health. So is the exclusion or marginalisation of indigenous voices from decisions about how public health systems work and how resources are distributed.

    Clinical skills treat ill health. But a health practitioner’s political values may influence how those skills are used.

    Some practitioners might try to find ways around policies and practices that disadvantage some patients over others. On the other hand, race may be a political determinant of health when decisions are made about the level of care given to one patient or another.

    A Radio New Zealand documentary series by Māori medical student Emma Espiner, Getting Better: A Year in the Life of a Māori Medical Student, shows how much influence political values have over the levels of care different people receive.

    Political determinants may also influence how health systems direct their resources, and what services are provided to which communities.

    The right to self-determination

    New Zealand, Australia, Canada and the United States initially opposed the United Nations’ Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, adopted by the UN in 2007. The declaration confirms that, like everybody, indigenous people have the right to self-determination.

    Self-determination includes people’s right to make their own health policy decisions. All four countries have since decided that this, and the declaration’s other presumptions, are reasonable aspirations and support it.

    But what they haven’t done is fully develop policies to put this aspiration into practice.

    In New Zealand, the Treaty of Waitangi affirms Māori rangatiratanga on one hand and citizenship on the other. In short, rangatiratanga means authority to make decisions over one’s own affairs. Citizenship means the political capacity to be part of state decision-making.

    The latest parliamentary select committee report makes a recommendation that could be developed to respect both rangatiratanga and citizenship. It could then help eliminate political inequities from the health system.

    Māori responsible for Māori health

    The committee recommended a government-funded entity be made responsible for eliminating health inequities for Māori. It should be given the authority and resources to do so, and should monitor and report annually on the health system.

    Just one month earlier, the government-commissioned Health and Disability System Review recommended such an entity, which it called a Māori Health Authority.

    This authority would be an independent advisory body. It would be responsible for monitoring and reporting on the health system’s effectiveness for Māori.

    Assuming the authority would have a representative and professionally skilled Māori membership, it could become an important policy advocate.

    But the review committee was divided on whether this authority should also be able to make decisions about funding Māori health services.

    Indigenous right to make decisions

    In 2009, a review into Australia’s health system recommended an independent indigenous purchasing authority. Through a tender process, the authority would procure primary health services for indigenous people, primarily from indigenous community-controlled health services.

    Indigenous communities would define their own health priorities. Their bids for public funding would be evaluated by an expert indigenous authority.

    The proposal was not accepted, but it is an instructive model for New Zealand. It would mean Māori values, aspirations and expectations would be foremost at every stage of the funding decision.

    It would also mean a Māori body would become accountable to Māori people for the effectiveness of policy decisions. It would strengthen Māori health providers and ensure their capacity to deliver health outcomes would be evaluated according to Māori criteria.

    Some claimants to the Waitangi Tribunal’s 2019 health inquiry argued the NUKA System of Care in Alaska was an example of what stronger Māori health providers could look like.

    The NUKA system doesn’t have patients; instead it serves “customer-owners”, the local indigenous people, who own the system and to whom the system is accountable. It has more independence from the state than Māori providers and takes an integrated and holistic approach to health care.

    The NUKA system is not entirely dependent on the state, as much of its funding comes from philanthropic sources. So it has a level of independence that may be possible for Māori as iwi (tribal) economic bases develop.

    An independent Māori authority with the power to monitor and report on service providers’ effectiveness, but also the power to discontinue their funding, would ensure meaningful Māori voice.

    Article by Dominic O'Sullivan, Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences, Auckland University of Technology, and Associate Professor of Political Science, Charles Sturt University. First published on The Conversation.

    The Conversation

    The Conversation

    @theconversation

    Want to be informed when this author publishes the next article?

    Save, embed, share, report
    0comments
    About this channel
    maori rights

    Maori rights

    New Zealand

    Protecting rights and interests of the indigenous Maori people.

    More from this channel

    Select between trending, latest and important content.
    Update26 Oct, 2020

    Only tangata whenua can be trusted to lead this process

    New Zealand history is set to be taught in our schools in 2022. But, after 30 years of tutoring about Te Tiriti issues, Catherine Delahunty has concerns about how we’ll go about that.

    E-Tangata

    Who should tell our history? - E-Tangata

    "We are still here, the descendants and beneficiaries, the marginalised and reviled — so how are we going to face the truth, and how can it be...
    Link01 Oct, 2020

    Te Ao with Moana

    #FullEpisode The second of our Te Tiriti o Waitangi specials, with Treaty...
    Update16 Sep, 2020

    "I feel like Te Wiki o Te Reo Māori has run parallel to my own pursuit of Tikanga Māori"

    ...it's about more than optics or the colour of your skin. It's what you feel inside rather than how you look outside that matters most. I've gained the greatest confidence in being a Māori journalist by embarking on a Te Reo journey. And it is a journey with many stops and starts along the way.

    Newshub

    Mike McRoberts: My journey as a Māori journalist | Newshub

    "Being Māori and in a prominent role in mainstream media is now a responsibility I embrace."
    Link13 Sep, 2020
    Stuff

    I’m worried distance learning will harm Māori cultural etiquette and understanding | Stuff.co.nz

    Witnessing your classmates infuse themselves into a kaupapa Māori related issue...
    Update11 Sep, 2020

    "They leave a legacy"

    "No infantry had a more distinguished record, or saw more fighting, or, alas, had such heavy casualties, as the Māori Battalion." The tūpāpaku of Epineha Ratapu will be mourned at Rangimarie Marae in Whakaoriori tomorrow, before being taken back to Tokomaru on Sunday. 

    Māori Television

    Farewells flow for Epineha 'Pine' Ratapu | Te Ao Māori News

    One of he last soldiers of the 28th Māori Battalion, and the last remaining member of C Company, Epineha Ratapu of Ngāti Porou, has died, aged 98.
    Link11 Sep, 2020
    waateanews

    Council organisations get hurry along on Māori framework

    An Auckland councillor says council controlled organisations don't seem to know...
    Link07 Sep, 2020

    Marae - Cultural misappropriation of our haka, whakairo and tā moko is nothing new. Oriini Kaipara traces the story behind the co-opting of her moko kauae. | Facebook

    No description provided
    Update06 Sep, 2020

    Stone said there were a range of reasons soldiers never received medals

    "One of the reasons that I got from one of the children of these soldiers is that it was a tikanga issue. Soldiers felt as though the medals needed to be presented to them face to face, kanohi ki te kanohi, but the policy of the time was that you...

    RNZ

    Māori Battalion war medals to be claimed after 75 years | RNZ News

    The never-received war medals of soldiers in the Māori Battalion's C Company are about to be claimed for the first time in 75 years.
    Update01 Sep, 2020

    Moss & Sampson are concerned that other Māori staff members might leave after Prof Hokowhitu leaves

    Moss says, “What we’re worried about is the future of our faculty and what the future of education looks like for Māori within Waikato and the quality of education that people are going to get if they come to Te Whare Wānanga o Waikato.”

    Māori Television

    University of Waikato students concerned about future of the university for Māori | Te Ao Māori News

    Students Luke Moss and Jasmine Sampson are worried about the future of the university’s faculty of Māori and indigenous studies, Te Pua Wānanga ki te...
    Article01 Sep, 2020

    Two inquiries find unfair treatment and healthcare for Māori. This is how we fix it

    An independent Māori authority with the power to monitor and report on service providers’ effectiveness, but also the power to discontinue their funding, would ensure meaningful Māori voice.
    Update28 Aug, 2020

    Do not allow yourself to be mokai to another.

    In earlier times, in the rūnanga, you could present your view, for instance, about whether to go to war against another tribe. Others would listen, absorb your perspective and then go away. There was no pressure to make a decision on the spot. This...

    E-Tangata

    Rangatiratanga in the age of conspiracy - E-Tangata

    Preserve the rangatiratanga of the mind, writes Rangi Kemara. Without it, you're a slave.
    Link21 Aug, 2020
    waateanews

    Māori framework sets ground rules for council

    Auckland Council has adopted an Outcomes for Māori Framework, five years after a...
    Event19 Aug, 2020

    Te Wā Tuku Reo Māori: Māori Language Moment

    Te Wā Tuku Reo Māori: Whāia kia kīia ai ko koe tētahi o te miriona. Te reo Māori is the language of New Zealand. And it still needs New Zealanders to keep it safe. Honour the past,...

    14 Sep, 2020

    6:30 AM

    Update16 Aug, 2020

    Moataane said closing Ngāti Rangi's borders will safeguard the community.

    “We have a duty to protect and care for our community and we are encouraging local authorities to step up and do the same. Closing our borders will eliminate the risk completely. It’s a no brainer and we don’t know why it hasn’t happened already. It’s not good enough."

    Māori Television

    Ngāti Rangi urges outsiders to stay away from Ruapehu area to safeguard community | Te Ao Māori News

    Ohakune-based iwi Ngāti Rangi are again urging outsiders to stay away from the Ruapehu area., the iwi said in a statement released today. This comes...
    Update15 Aug, 2020

    This govt has been light on advocacy for Māori when it clashes with the philosophy of universalism

    In 2020 we still have many of the conditions which led to the appalling death rate of almost 5% of all Māori from influenza in 1918-19. We are still dealing with systemic racism, the underprovision of health services in areas where Māori live, material poverty, and the consequences of the state-led destruction of our health-protective factors – language, land, culture, resources, whānau.

    the Guardian

    New Zealand must learn lessons of 1918 pandemic and protect Māori from Covid-19 | Opinion | The Guardian

    Chronic health problems and a lack of access to hospitals threaten another calamity for indigenous people unless they are protected
    Link13 Aug, 2020
    waateanews

    Better cancer screening call from Māori health inquiry

    Parliament’s Māori Affairs Committee is calling for an equity positive lung...
    Link11 Aug, 2020
    Measurement Standards Laboratory

    Rediscovering the measurement system used by pre-European Māori | Measurement Standards Laboratory

    Rediscovering the measurement system used by pre-European Māori - a student...

    Select your country

    The NextElection network is fully customized to each country.

    Looks like you are in USA. Click on your country flag to proceed.

    India
    United States of America
    New Zealand