NextElection - Make it count!
India
English
0
  • Search

  • Updates
  • Topics
  • Featured
  • Leaders
  • Parties

AboutContactTermsPrivacy
    ⚡ Powered by MainCross
    Dim the Navigation panel when not in use
    RTI - right to informationArticle26 Jul, 2019
    Last edited: 27 Jul, 2019, 4:32 AM

    Fact Check: How true are some of the Government’s statements on RTI? - Part 1

    An Office Memorandum released in April 2013 clearly mentions the launch of online portal to file RTI and it was during the UPA government. The claim made by the minister is hence FALSE.

    Claim: NDA Government launched the RTI online portal for 24/7 filing of RTI applications.

    Fact: An Office Memorandum released in April 2013 clearly mentions the launch of online portal to file RTI and it was during the UPA government. The claim made by the minister ishence FALSE.  

    The Minister of State in the Department of Personnel & Training (DoPT),  Dr. Jitendra Singh on 19 July, 2019, during the introduction of the  Right to Information (Amendment) Bill, 2019, spoke at length about the NDA government’s achievements and initiatives for RTI. He made multiple claims while introducing the bill in the Lok Sabha. Similar claims were tweeted by the BJP later. In this story, we look at three specific claims made by the minister.

    The amendment is now passed by both the houses

    On 19 July 2019, the Right to Information (Amendment) Bill, 2019 was introduced in the Lok Sabha by the government. The Bill, which was later passed on Monday, 22 July, had proposals which gave powers to the Central Government to fix salaries and tenures as well as set the service conditions for the Information Commissioners at both the Central and State level. This sparked a debate in both the houses of parliament since a majority of the opposition were against the bill stating that the bill was not sent for parliamentary scrutiny and that it lacked legislative competence. The bill was also referred to as the RTI ‘Elimination’ bill by the opposition.

    During the debate, Dr. Jitendra Singh, made a few claims regarding the role of the NDA Government in upholding the objective of the Right To Information Act of 2005 that was formulated to empower citizens, promote transparency and accountability in the functioning of the government, contain corruption and make democracy work for the people in the real sense.

    When was the RTI Online portal launched?

    One of the claims made by the minister is that the NDA government launched the RTI online portal to ensure that citizens can file RTIs 24 hours a day instead of it being a 10am to 5pm affair.

    In order to substantiate his point stating that the NDA government has always been working towards the refinement of the act, the minister said that it was the Modi-led NDA government that introduced the online web portal for RTI. But an office memorandum (OM) dated 22 April, 2013released by the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions had details regarding the launch of the online portal for RTI along with its link.

    In this OM,  it has been clearly stated that ‘a Web Portal namely RTI Online with url https://rtionline.gov.in has been launched. This portal, developed by NIC, is a facility for the Indian Citizens to online file RTI applications and first appeals and also to make online payment of RTI fees…’ It has also been mentioned that the facility was then available only for the Department of Personnel Training and had details regarding the plans to extend the same to other ministries.

    When this memorandum was released on 22 April, 2013, the then Minister of State of the department was V. Narayanaswamy. The UPA government was in power in the year 2013.  

    Also, in the press release made on 17 March 2017, we can see that the Secretary, DoPT, B P Sharma mentioned that the RTI Online Portal was launched in August 2013. The Union Minister had mentioned that the government was persuading more states and departments to adopt this. The Secretary, DoPT, further added that as on 1 April, 2016, only 477 Public Authorities (PAs) were aligned with the portal. An additional 1,363 more PAs aligned with the same by 17 March, 2017. Further, 198 PAs under the Delhi Government also adopted the portal. Plans to include PAs from Puducherry and Chandigarh by the end of April 2017 have also been mentioned in the press release. From this, we can infer that the NDA Government did take initiatives to include more PAs in the portal. But, to say that the NDA government launched the portal is not true.

    Factly.in

    Factly.in

    @factlyIN

    Want to be informed when this author publishes the next article?

    Save, embed, share, report
    0comments
    About this channel
    RTI - right to information

    RTI - right to information

    India

    RTI is a legislation that allows citizen to access information from public authorities.

    More from this channel

    Select between trending, latest and important content.
    Link16 Jan, 2020
    India Today

    Home ministry dumbfounded by RTI seeking details of 'Tukde Tukde Gang' members

    The petitioner said he is serious about his RTI application and if the home...
    Opinion05 Dec, 2019

    The mother of RTI

    The RTI gives way to the government's duty to publish. The Centre and all states must emulate Rajasthan.

    ThePrint

    Rajasthan’s Jan Soochna, mother of RTI, is the ultimate weapon against petty corruption

    The Right to Information gives way to the government’s duty to publish. The Centre and all states must emulate Rajasthan.
    Link02 Dec, 2019

    What is RTI? - Know the Basics || Decode S3E9 || Factly

    #RTI #RTIAct #Factly The Right to Information is an important right enjoyed by...
    Article27 Nov, 2019

    Fact Check: Has there been a reduction in the number of RTI applications filed in the last few years?

    Addressing a RTI convention, Home Minister Amit Shah mentioned it is the reduction in the number of RTI applications and not the increase that shows the real success of RTI. Here is a fact-check.
    Article04 Aug, 2019

    Fact Check: How true are some of the Government’s statements on RTI? - Part 3

    The RTI bill was introduced in Parliament in Dec 2004 and was referred to a standing committee which then submitted its report in March 2005. Thus, the claim that the act was done in haste is FALSE.
    Article01 Aug, 2019

    Fact Check: How true are some of the Government’s statements on RTI? - Part 2

    As per the RTI Act, the leader of the single largest group in the opposition of the Government will be deemed as the Leader of Opposition. Thus, this claim is also FALSE.
    Link26 Jul, 2019
    The Indian Express

    BJP, which used RTI against the Congress regime, now looks terrified of it

    The measure of progress of any democracy is the level of empowerment of ordinary...
    Article26 Jul, 2019

    Fact Check: How true are some of the Government’s statements on RTI? - Part 1

    An Office Memorandum released in April 2013 clearly mentions the launch of online portal to file RTI and it was during the UPA government. The claim made by the minister is hence FALSE.
    Opinion25 Jul, 2019

    RTI gets an undesired makeover

    The new RTI Amendment Bill that the government is introducing is quite concerning. With the bill aimed at given the government more power to control tenure, allowances etc of Information Commissions, it raises big questions about influence, transparency and freedom when it comes to the working of the commissions. So, like a friend says, this changes the RTI forever. Does it?
    Link20 Jul, 2019
    The Economic Times

    Bill to amend RTI introduced amid opposition protests

    "Bill aims at institutionalisation, streamlining and ease of delivery of RTI...
    Link06 Jul, 2019
    The Indian Express

    Gujarat: Ex-BJP MP Dinu Solanki, 6 others guilty of killing RTI activist

    Amit Jethva was shot dead on July 20, 2010, by two assailants outside the...
    Link27 Apr, 2019
    https://www.livemint.com

    RBI gets SC ultimatum on RTI Act disclosures

    Central bank told to share information on annual bank inspection reports.The RBI...
    Link15 Mar, 2019
    The Hindu

    RTI trumps Official Secrets Act, says SC

    Justice Joseph cites information law as government seeks to keep Rafale pricing...
    Link24 Nov, 2018
    The Hindu

    RTI request to see RTI Amendment Bill denied

    No transparency in appointment process, says petitioner.
    Link23 Nov, 2018
    The Hindu

    We weren’t consulted on RTI Act amendments: CIC

    The Commission discussed them internally but chose not to take a stand

    Select your country

    The NextElection network is fully customized to each country.

    Looks like you are in USA. Click on your country flag to proceed.

    India
    United States of America
    New Zealand